Get 80% off your plan for your first 3 months*
Guide

How to choose the right payroll software for accountants and bookkeepers

Evaluate payroll software for your practice, covering STP Phase 2, Payday Super, and multi-client management.

Woman working on her laptop

Written by Jotika Teli—Certified Public Accountant with 24 years of experience. Read Jotika's full bio

Published Tuesday 10 November 2026

Table of contents

Key takeaways

  • Compliance readiness is non-negotiable. Your payroll software must handle STP Phase 2 reporting and Payday Super, which now applies, so employers must pay super each payday rather than quarterly.
  • Integration drives practice efficiency. Payroll software that connects directly to your accounting platform eliminates double-handling and creates automatic journal entries for every pay run.
  • Multi-client management separates good software from great. The right platform lets you manage payroll across dozens of clients from a single dashboard, freeing up capacity for advisory work.
  • Employee self-service reduces your admin burden. Features like digital payslips, leave requests, and timesheet submissions shift routine tasks away from you and your clients.

Why your payroll software choice matters for your practice

The payroll software you choose shapes how efficiently your practice operates and how well you can serve your clients. The right platform reduces compliance admin and creates capacity for strategic advice across your client base.

This decision carries more weight now than ever. With Payday Super in effect since 1 July 2026, employers must pay superannuation each payday rather than quarterly. That's a fundamental shift in payroll processing frequency. Your software needs to handle it without creating extra work for your team.

At the same time, Single Touch Payroll (STP) Phase 2 continues to raise the bar for reporting granularity. Your payroll platform is the backbone of your compliance workflow, and it gives your practice the data it needs to offer advisory services.

For practices advising multiple clients across different industries, the stakes multiply. A platform that works for one client but falls short for another creates inconsistency. That adds unnecessary complexity to your operations.

Compliance with Australian payroll regulations

Regulatory compliance is the baseline. Payroll software that keeps pace with Australian tax and employment law keeps your clients' payroll compliant, so you can choose it with confidence. Focus on four compliance areas: STP Phase 2 support, Payday Super compliance, award interpretation, and Pay As You Go (PAYG) withholding accuracy.

STP Phase 2 reporting

STP Phase 2 is mandatory for all employers. Your software must support disaggregated reporting of gross pay into its components each pay event. This includes income types, country codes, child support deductions, and allowance breakdowns. Software that handles this natively saves you from manual reclassification and reduces Australian Taxation Office (ATO) queries.

Pay close attention to how the software maps income types. Phase 2 requires separate reporting of salary and wages, closely held payees, working holiday makers, and other categories. If you're onboarding a new client whose previous payroll system didn't disaggregate correctly, reclassifying historical data should be straightforward.

Payday Super compliance

Your payroll software needs to keep client super compliant now that Payday Super applies. Super must be paid each payday and reach the employee's fund within seven business days. Xero's Payday Super resources outline the key changes in detail. The super guarantee rate sits at 12% of qualifying earnings, which is broader than ordinary time earnings. The maximum contribution base for 2026–27 is $270,830 per year. The ATO's Small Business Superannuation Clearing House (SBSCH) has also closed.

Your payroll software should calculate super on qualifying earnings automatically and trigger payments on each pay cycle. It should also track whether contributions reach funds within the required timeframe. When it does, your clients stay clear of new super guarantee charge penalties, and you can recommend it with confidence.

Fair Work and award interpretation

The Fair Work Act requires employers to keep employee records for seven years. Modern Awards add layers of complexity: penalty rates, overtime calculations, allowances, and classification structures that vary by industry. The national minimum wage is $26.44 per hour ($1,004.90 per week).

Look for software that keeps client pay compliant by incorporating award interpretation rules and updating automatically when Fair Work Commission decisions take effect. It should also flag underpayment risks before they become audit issues, giving your practice confidence in its choice.

PAYG withholding and record-keeping

Payroll software must apply current PAYG withholding tax scales accurately. It should update automatically when the ATO revises rates each financial year. The ATO requires businesses to keep payroll records for five years, alongside the seven-year Fair Work requirement covered above.

Software that automates tax scale updates and maintains a compliant record archive removes two common failure points from your workflow. Look for platforms that store records in a searchable, exportable format. This lets you respond quickly to ATO audits or Fair Work enquiries on behalf of your clients.

Integration with accounting platforms

When payroll and accounting sit in separate systems, you're doubling your data entry and increasing the risk of errors in client submissions. Integrated software eliminates that problem.

Modern integrated platforms automatically create journal entries for every pay run. Expenses, liabilities, and superannuation obligations flow directly into the general ledger using your assigned account codes. You don't need to reconcile between two systems or re-key figures.

Xero's integrated payroll and accounting software connects payroll data directly to the ledger. Every pay run generates automatic journal entries, and payroll-specific reports sit alongside your accounting data. This means you can pull a complete picture of a client's financial position without switching between platforms.

Integration also matters for your app stack. Practices that rely on time tracking, rostering, or HR tools need payroll software that connects to those platforms. The Xero App Store offers access to over 1,000 integrations, so you can build a connected workflow around your clients' needs.

Ease of use for practices and clients

A powerful feature set means nothing if your team and clients struggle to use the software. Payroll touches multiple people across a practice and its client base, so usability has a direct impact on efficiency.

Consider how intuitive the software is for your team members who process pay runs. Then consider the client experience: can business owners review payroll summaries, approve leave, and access reports without needing your help? The fewer support calls you field on payroll mechanics, the more time you have for higher-value work.

Key usability features to evaluate include:

  • a single dashboard showing total pay runs, leave to approve and timesheets pending across clients
  • client-friendly interfaces that let business owners delegate tasks to their teams without your intervention
  • guided STP reporting that walks users through each lodgement step to reduce errors
  • mobile access, so you and your clients can check payroll status from any device

Scalability and multi-client management

If you're managing payroll for 40 or more clients, your software needs to scale without adding headcount to your team. The difference between a scalable platform and a limited one becomes clear when you're running pay runs for dozens of businesses in a single week.

Automated processes are the key. Unlike manual workflows that require proportionally more time and staff as your client list grows, automated payroll scales without friction. Your software should handle varying pay frequencies, different award structures, and a mix of full-time, part-time, and casual employees across your entire client base.

Scalability also means handling complexity across industries. A hospitality client with casual staff on rotating rosters has very different payroll needs from a professional services firm with salaried employees. Your software should accommodate both without requiring separate setups or workarounds.

Xero Payroll Manager gives accountants and bookkeepers a single dashboard to view and manage all their payroll clients. You can see which pay runs are due, which need attention, and where issues have been flagged, all without logging into individual client files. Combined with Xero Partner Hub for broader practice management, you get a complete view of your workload and client status.

Employee self-service and Xero Me

Self-service features shift routine admin tasks away from you and your clients. When employees can access their own payslips, request leave, submit timesheets, and lodge expense claims, the volume of queries landing on your desk drops significantly.

For your clients' businesses, this translates to less time spent chasing approvals and tracking down paperwork. Managers can approve or reject leave requests directly, and employees get transparency over their own records.

Xero Me is a self-service app that gives employees direct access to their payroll information. Staff can request leave, submit timesheets, view payslips, and lodge expense claims for reimbursement. It reduces the admin load on business owners and, by extension, on your practice.

When evaluating self-service features, consider the permissions model. The best platforms let business owners grant specific access levels, so a team leader can approve leave requests without seeing salary details. This layered approach keeps sensitive information secure while distributing routine approvals across the organisation.

Reporting, analytics, and compliance insights

Payroll data is rich with insights that go well beyond running a compliant pay cycle. The right reporting capabilities can transform your payroll service from a compliance obligation into an advisory conversation starter.

At a minimum, your payroll software should provide clear reporting on:

  • super guarantee obligations: track contributions per employee, flag shortfalls before the seven-business-day Payday Super deadline, and reconcile payments against fund confirmations
  • PAYG withholding summaries: prepare Business Activity Statements (BAS) with accurate, up-to-date withholding data
  • leave liability: show clients their accrued leave balances and the financial impact on their business
  • workforce costs: break down labour costs by department, role or location to support budgeting and forecasting conversations
  • STP lodgement status: confirm each pay event has been reported to the ATO successfully

Beyond compliance reporting, the advisory opportunity is significant. Payroll data can reveal patterns in overtime costs, seasonal staffing needs, and labour efficiency that your clients may not see on their own. The right software makes it easy to extract these insights and present them in a format that supports decision-making.

Practices using Xero can access payroll employee summaries, activity reports, and real-time dashboards. These reports sit alongside accounting data, so you can connect payroll trends to broader financial performance when advising clients.

Cloud-based accessibility and security

Desktop-installed payroll software ties your team to specific devices and creates version control headaches. Cloud-based platforms solve both problems while adding layers of security that on-premise solutions struggle to match.

Payroll data is sensitive. Employee addresses, bank account details, Tax File Numbers, and superannuation fund information all need strong protection. Under the Privacy Act 1988 and the Australian Privacy Principles, you have obligations to safeguard this data. Cloud payroll software with encryption, role-based access controls, and automatic backups helps you meet those obligations without managing infrastructure yourself.

Cloud access also means your team can process payroll from anywhere. Whether your practice operates from a single office or has staff working remotely across different states, everyone works from the same live data. You can set granular permissions so team members see only what's relevant to their role. You can also share specific reports with clients by adding them as viewers.

For practices with team members across multiple time zones or states, cloud-based payroll also simplifies collaboration on time-sensitive tasks like end-of-month pay runs and BAS lodgements. Everyone accesses the same current data, reducing the risk of version conflicts or outdated figures.

Xero's cloud payroll software encrypts data and protects payroll information with multiple layers of security. Because records sit in the cloud, you can keep and retrieve payroll records for as long as the ATO and Fair Work require.

Why choose Xero for your practice's payroll

Xero brings together the features that matter most for accounting and bookkeeping practices evaluating payroll software.

Xero payroll is STP Phase 2 compliant and Payday Super ready, so your compliance obligations are handled from day one. Payroll integrates directly with Xero's accounting ledger, creating automatic journal entries and eliminating double-handling. Xero Payroll Manager lets you manage all your payroll clients from a single dashboard, and Xero Partner Hub ties payroll into your broader practice management workflow.

As a Xero partner, you also get free practice-use Xero software, 24/7 partner support, and listing in the Xero Advisor Directory. Every partner tier includes Xero Partner Hub with tax and workpapers tools, Silver-tier partners and above get practice management tools, and Syft Analytics is available on eligible plans, so you can build a connected practice that scales without adding overhead.

The Xero App Store gives you access to over 1,000 integrations, covering everything from time tracking and rostering to HR management and expense workflows. This means you can recommend a complete, connected software stack to clients rather than a patchwork of disconnected tools.

Strengthen your practice's payroll capability with Xero

Choosing the right payroll software is a strategic decision for your practice. The right platform should handle STP Phase 2 and Payday Super compliance while integrating with your accounting workflow. It should also scale across your entire client base without adding overhead.

Xero gives you compliance confidence, integrated data, multi-client management, and a partner program designed to help practices grow. Join the partner program to get started.

FAQs on choosing payroll software for accountants

Here are some frequently asked questions about selecting payroll software for accounting and bookkeeping practices in Australia.

How do I check my clients are set up for Payday Super?

Audit each client's super payment process, confirm their payroll software supports payday-frequency contributions, and check employee fund details, since incorrect details cause payment failures under the seven-business-day deadline. Clients who used the ATO's Small Business Superannuation Clearing House need an alternative clearing house or direct fund payments, since it has closed.

How do I set up multi-client payroll management efficiently?

Standardise payroll workflows across clients and assign role-based permissions so team members process pay runs only for their allocated clients. Keeping all clients on one platform also makes onboarding new staff simpler, since they only learn one system.

What's the difference between qualifying earnings and ordinary time earnings for super?

Since 1 July 2026, qualifying earnings have replaced ordinary time earnings as the base for super, combining ordinary time earnings with salary sacrifice amounts and certain other payments. For most employers the total super owed stays the same, but your payroll software needs to apply the new definition correctly.

How do I evaluate whether payroll software handles award interpretation properly?

Test the software against the Modern Awards your clients use, checking penalty rates, overtime and allowances for different employee classifications. Also confirm it updates automatically when the Fair Work Commission issues new decisions.

How do I assess a payroll vendor's security credentials?

Ask whether the provider holds independently audited certifications such as ISO 27001 or SOC 2, and how it handles notifications under the Notifiable Data Breaches scheme. Confirm where your clients' data is hosted and how the provider protects Tax File Numbers and bank details.

What happens to the Small Business Superannuation Clearing House after 1 July 2026?

The ATO's SBSCH closed on 1 July 2026 when Payday Super took effect. Former users now pay super directly through their payroll software or an alternative clearing house.

Become a Xero partner

Join the Xero community of accountants and bookkeepers. Collaborate with your peers, support your clients and boost your practice.

Disclaimer

Xero does not provide accounting, tax, business or legal advice. This guide has been provided for information purposes only. You should consult your own professional advisors for advice directly relating to your business or before taking action in relation to any of the content provided.